Fallacy.in

Illicit major

Illicit major is a formal fallacy committed in a categorical syllogism that is invalid because its major term is undistributed in the major premise but distributed in the conclusion.

All dogs are mammals
No cats are dogs
Therefore, no cats are mammals

In this argument, the major term is 'mammals'. This is distributed in the conclusion (the last statement) because we are making a claim about a property of all mammals: that they are not cats. However, it is not distributed in the major premise (the first statement) where we are only talking about a property of some mammals: Only some mammals are dogs.

The error is in assuming that the converse of the first statement (that all mammals are dogs) is also true.

Comment fallacy in illicit major on Reddit to explain this fallacy. ?